Takes some listening
4
By bhzimmy88
This is a deep, complex, interconnected, but a few times, slightly unreachable album. But mostly it is a wonderful adventure and appreciated return from this amazing trio. Sean Watkins shines ever so bright. His songs, while following the more complex mantra this time out, still play like real "songs". His "Hollywood Ending", "Strangers" and "Stones Throw" are both fresh and deeply textured, yet also quite singable and memorable. Sarah and Chris also shine in many spots. "To The Airport" is a marvel. And "Where The Long Line Leads" is instantly a classic. There are just a few times when I think the complexity overwhelms the song-even thought he lyrics are finely crafted- with unmemorable meandering melodies that don't really work. But with obviously so much heart and soul put into this project it's hard not to just applaud and cheer these guys. Welcome back!
A Glorious Failure
1
By *none*
The great thing about having both the Punch Brothers and Nickle Creek is that Chris Thile could swing both ways-manic/complex with PB and more melodic and song oriented with NC. This is not Nickle Creek-this is Chris Thile bringing way too much of his PBros persona into this glorious trio. Not a memorable melody to be found. It all "wows" me but nothing moves me. I am in awe of their musicanship, but I play Nickle Creek to hear amazing songs and stellar playing, not to be hit over the head with overly complex arrangements. I got PBros for that. I love these guys but this is a ginormous and glorious failure. Not nearly enough heart and warmth. Seeing them in concert very soon. Hope its a mix of old and new, cause if they play too much of this album I'm gonna walk away very dissapointed.
Truly amazing, but unplayable by fans
3
By jarombra
They get an A+ for pushing the limits of acoustic trio arrangement. But there isn't a single song on this album that a fan could play on their own instrument; no bouncy filddle/mando tunes whatsoever. As a result the listener is basically just a dazzled consumer, which is kind of lame. Perhaps this album is ultimately another Thile ego flex, but I still dig it if only for its undeniably impressive complexity and musicianship.
Masterpiece
5
By ultradawg
in the tradition of Brian Wilson. Deep and musically satisfying
More like the Punch Brothers.
3
By SMH Bob
Needs up tunes
what happened to melodies?
2
By Feck99
their first album was outstanding, this one? Where are the songs? The melodies?
